Eleven Days by Stav Sherez


Esta entrada es bilingüe, para ver la versión en castellano desplazarse hacia abajo

Faber and Faber, 2013. Kindle edition. 636 KB. ASIN: B00BE64W1W. 380 pages.

Eleven Days

Following on from  A Dark Redemption (you can see my review HERE), Eleven Days is the second book in the Carrigan & Miller series. The action is set a few months after the events narrated in the first book and eleven days before Christmas. A building is burning in Bayswater, one of the most exclusive areas of London. But it’s no ordinary family home, it’s a convent for a small religious community, the Sisters of Suffering. The diocese has confirmed that ten nuns are living on the premises. Assistant Chief Constable Quinn lives nearby and takes a personal interest in the case. He immediately calls DSI Branch. ACC Quinn wants Detective Inspector Jack Carrigan in to the investigation even if there is no indication that the fire has been intentionally started. When finally the fire is successfully controlled and the access to the building is safe, the ten bodies appear grouped together in one room, but there’s another victim separated from the others. It seems like the ten nuns were gathered around their evening meal when the fire begun, but none of them tried to escape the flames. However the identity of the eleventh victim is unknown. Although the bodies are in pretty bad shape, the eleventh victim had received a strong blow in the skull and it can be ensured that she was alive when the fire reached her. The pathologist also shows that five of the nuns had been tortured in an identical way some thirty or forty years ago. Besides, the samples taken because of a funny smell in the chapel, have tested positive for cocaine.

This is probably the book I was awaiting with the greatest interest this year and, although I have not been disappointed, I don’t think it is as good as the previous one. I have really enjoyed reading it, and I like Sherez’s writing style. The plot is quite interesting and well-developed. The solution is brilliant. And Sherez is very brave when tackling such difficult topics as the Catholic Church, the liberation theology, the terrorism of Shining Path in Peru, etc. My only problem has been with some chapters, which in my view are not totally credible or, at least to me, are somewhat farfetched. However, I look forward to reading the next instalment in the series with the same interest as before.

My rating: 3/5.

You can read more from Stav Sherez at www.stavsherez.com or keep in touch via Twitter @stavsherez. He is the author of The Devil’s Playground, The Black Monastery, and the Carrigan & Miller crime novels A Dark Redemption and Eleven Days.

Eleven Days has been reviewed by Sarah at Crimepieces, Suzigun at Novel Heights, at Crime Fiction Lover, Majanka at I heart reading among others. 

The Unseen World of Stav Sherez by Eva Dolan

Faber & Faber

Once días, de Stav Sherez

A continuación de A Dark Redemption (mi reseña está AQUÍ), Once días es el segundo libro de la serie protagonizada por Carrigan y Miller. La acción se desarrolla unos meses después de los acontecimientos narrados en el primer libro y once días antes de la Navidad. Un edificio se está quemando en Bayswater, una de las zonas más exclusivas de Londres. Pero no alberga una casa común y corriente, es un convento de una pequeña comunidad religiosa, las Hermanas del Sufrimiento. La diócesis ha confirmado que diez monjas viven en sus instalaciones. El Jefe Superior de Policía Adjunto Quinn vive cerca y tiene un interés personal en el caso. Llama inmediatamente al DSI Branch. ACC Quinn quiere al detective Inspector Jack Carrigan en la investigación, aunque no hay indicios de que el fuego se haya iniciado intencionalmente. Cuando por fin el fuego está controlado con éxito y el acceso al edificio es seguro, diez cuerpos aparecen agrupados juntos en una habitación, pero hay otra víctima separada de las otras. Parece que las diez monjas estaban reunidas alrededor de la cena, cuando comenzó el fuego, pero ninguna de ellas trató de escapar de las llamas. Sin embargo se desconoce la identidad de la undécima víctima. Aunque los cuerpos están en muy mal estado, la undécima víctima había recibido un fuerte golpe en el cráneo y se puede asegurar que estaba viva cuando el fuego la alcanzó. El patólogo también muestra que cinco de las monjas habían sido torturadas de forma idéntica hace unos treinta o cuarenta años. Además, las muestras tomadas a causa de un extraño olor en la capilla, han dado positivo por cocaína.

Este es probablemente el libro que estaba esperando con mayor interés este año y, aunque no me ha decepcionado, creo que no es tan bueno como el anterior. Realmente he disfrutado de su lectura, y me gusta la manera de escribir de Sherez. La trama es muy interesante y está bien desarrollada. La solución es brillante. Y Sherez es muy valiente al abordar temas tan difíciles como la Iglesia Católica, la teología de la liberación, el terrorismo de Sendero Luminoso en Perú, etc.  Mi único problema ha sido con algunos capítulos, que en mi opinión no son totalmente creíbles o, al menos para mi, resultan algo exagerados. Sin embargo, espero leer la siguiente entrega de esta serie con el mismo interés que antes.

Mi valoración: 3/5.

13 thoughts on “Eleven Days by Stav Sherez”

  1. José Ignacio – Thanks for this thoughtful and well-written review. It’s been so interesting for me to see the different views about this novel. It’s on my TBR pile so I’ll be very interested to see what I think of it when I get there…

  2. Sounds great José Ignacio, thanks very much – a completely new author for me. I should start with the first one byt the sound of it – thanks.

  3. I liked the religious aspect too Jose and the depiction of the convent. I’ve passed on my copy of the book to someone I think will also like the subject matter.

  4. Oh, I thought I would read this as I’m interested in matters concerning liberation theology and the Catholic Church, but your critique has me dismayed. I’d have to buy the book, and I don’t do that unless reviewers agree that it’s a book worth my doing that.

    1. Kathy – I trust that my review will not prevent you from reading it. It’s worth reading, moreover if your are interested in these matters,

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.